The Best Bagel Shop and Sandwich Shop in Bayville and Lanoka Harbor

Our Menu

Do you love gourmet sandwiches? Bagel sandwiches? Deli Sandwiches? So do we! Our made-to-order Handcrafted Breakfast, Brunch and Lunches combine high-quality meats, cheeses and fresh vegetables. You can build your own gourmet sandwiches by selecting any of our fresh-baked bagel experience that is distinctly Oh What a Bagel.

Our classic, signature and gourmet bagels are fresh-baked in-store every day. Pair them with our signature double-whipped shmear to create your own flavor combinations.

Bayville Location
Oh What a Bagel
657 Route 9 (Atlantic City Blvd)
Bayville, NJ 08721
Phone Number: (732) 269-8828

Lanoka Harbor Location
Oh What a Bagel
627 N Main Street (Route 9)
Lanoka Harbor, NJ 08734
Phone Number: (609) 693-8828

Hours of Operation
Monday - Friday 5:30am - 1:00pm
Saturday & Sunday
6:00am - 1:00pm
Lanoka Harbor:
Open Every Day 6:30am - 1pm