The Best Bagel Shop and Sandwich Shop in Bayville and Lanoka Harbor
We Now Have 2 Locations To Serve You Better
Bayville (732) 269-8828 and Lanoka Harbor (609) 693-8828
FREE Delivery or Call Ahead for Pickup at Your Location

Hand rolled bagels, bagel sandwiches,
fresh salads, and specialty cream cheeses.

View Our Menu

Watch for our delicious blackboard specials for breakfast and lunch.

View Our Weekly Specials


Office breakfasts or lunches, birthday parties, family gatherings, or any other.

View Our Catering Menu


Bayville Location
Oh What a Bagel
657 Route 9 (Atlantic City Blvd)
Bayville, NJ 08721
Phone Number: (732) 269-8828

Lanoka Harbor Location
Oh What a Bagel
627 N Main Street (Route 9)
Lanoka Harbor, NJ 08734
Phone Number: (609) 693-8828

Hours of Operation
Monday - Friday 5:30am - 1:00pm
Saturday & Sunday
6:00am - 1:00pm
Lanoka Harbor:
Open Every Day 6:30am - 1pm